Five out of nine USB flash drives failed to properly transfer voting data in Milwaukee's primary election.
That jaw-dropping detail emerged Tuesday night as results from the hotly contested Democratic gubernatorial primary between Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley and Francesca Hong ground to a halt. Election officials blamed a so-called "human error" for the fiasco, according to reports, but critics aren't buying the innocent explanation one bit.
Here's what went down. Staff at Milwaukee's Central Count facility were tasked with downloading election results onto USB drives from nine tabulators. Somehow, on five of those machines, someone hit the wrong button and grabbed the audit log instead of the actual vote tallies. That means roughly 15,000 ballots sat in limbo while everyone scrambled to figure out what happened.
Milwaukee Election Commission Executive Director Paulina Gutiérrez held a midnight press conference to explain the mess, telling reporters that "we're all human, and humans can make errors." She and her team then headed back to the operations center with a police escort to retrieve the correct data and reprint results for comparison.
The commission later confirmed in a statement that no ballots were lost, altered, or needed recounting. The actual vote totals stayed intact on the tabulators the entire time. The screw-up only affected how quickly those numbers got reported publicly.
But that explanation hasn't exactly calmed nerves. Republican officials and election integrity advocates slammed the incident as "complete incompetence." Former Milwaukee Election Commissioner Claire Woodall raised serious questions about whether the person handling the downloads was even properly trained on the machines. She told Votebeat that the same mistake happening five separate times "seems more like a training issue" than a simple one-off accident.
A local journalist caught the error unfolding in real time and tagged the FBI on social media, adding another layer of intrigue to an already messy situation. Meanwhile, NBC News number cruncher Steve Kornacki could barely contain his frustration on live television. "We waited 90 minutes for them," he said. "They did this whole procession, and then we find out there's nothing on the sticks."
Gutiérrez noted that download times varied by machine, with some completing the transfer in three minutes while others took around ten. That inconsistency apparently contributed to the confusion.
The corrected data finally came through just after 1 a.m. Milwaukee County Clerk George Christenson addressed reporters afterward, emphasizing that transparency and security remained the top priorities.
This latest debacle lands at possibly the worst time for election administrators in Democratic-led jurisdictions, which are already facing heightened scrutiny from GOP lawmakers over ballot-counting and reporting problems. Several similar incidents across blue states have triggered investigations and fueled ongoing allegations from President Trump that elections have been compromised.
Whether this was genuinely an innocent mistake or a symptom of deeper systemic problems, one thing is crystal clear. Milwaukee's election team had one job, and they botched it on the biggest stage imaginable.
Like what you see? Then sign up for our Free Newsletter
