The NYPD flatly refused to send officers with the NYC first lady on a personal trip to Syria and Lebanon.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration got caught in a deeply embarrassing situation this week after his own spokesperson announced that police would escort his wife, Rama Duwaji, on her planned September 20 journey to the Middle East, only for the NYPD to come out swinging with a very public "absolutely not" the very next day. The whole fiasco, according to reports, has exposed a glaring communication breakdown between City Hall and the police department.
Here's how it all went down. Mamdani spokeswoman Dora Pekec told reporters that the first lady's security team would accompany Duwaji on her visit to see relatives in Syria and Lebanon, claiming it was done at the NYPD's own recommendation. A source with knowledge of the arrangements even confirmed that Duwaji herself had requested the escort and that City Hall had signed off.
Then Tuesday morning, the NYPD dropped a bombshell statement. The department said it categorically does not deploy officers to countries carrying Level 4 State Department travel advisories for non-investigative purposes. Both Syria and Lebanon currently sit on the government's "Do Not Travel" list. Case closed, as far as the department was concerned.
So how did City Hall announce something the NYPD apparently never agreed to? One insider offered a brutally simple answer. "They never checked with the commissioner," the source said. Ouch.
Mamdani tried to clean things up by calling it a "miscommunication" during a PIX11 interview, confirming his wife would ultimately make the trip without any NYPD detail. But the damage was already done.
Former NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton did not mince words about the whole mess. He called the idea of sending city cops into countries with the highest possible danger warnings "ill-advised" and said such a mission would be costly and require serious federal coordination. He also made clear that the conflicting public statements from City Hall and Commissioner Jessica Tisch's department represent a failure that needs fixing immediately.
David Catalfamo, a former communications director for ex-Governor George Pataki, piled on as well. He argued that political staffers tried to get ahead of the story without consulting law enforcement professionals first. His assessment of the situation was blunt. "Going to Syria and Lebanon is not like buying a ticket on Amtrak," he said.
The 29-year-old Duwaji, a Syrian-American artist whom Mamdani has called a "private person," reportedly traveled internationally without police protection as recently as July. Sources confirmed this particular trip was entirely personal and had nothing to do with official city business.
Making all of this even spicier is the fact that Mamdani and Tisch have been publicly butting heads on multiple issues since the mayor took office in January, including disagreements over Israel and various policing policies. Despite those tensions, the two have continued showing up together at public safety events, putting on a united front while apparently failing to communicate behind closed doors.
This whole episode is a masterclass in how NOT to handle interagency coordination. Somebody in City Hall owes the NYPD a very long phone call.
Like what you see? Then sign up for our Free Newsletter
Last edited by a moderator:
